Belgian Public Law and European Union Law: Interactions, Challenges and Perspectives
This event, held in Brussels, BEL, focuses on the intricate relationship between Belgian public law and European Union law. It aims to explore the various interactions, challenges, and future perspectives arising from the integration of these two legal systems. The conference provides a platform for legal scholars, practitioners, and policymakers to discuss the evolving landscape of public law within the European context.
Committees & topics
Topics
The Influence of EU Law on Belgian Constitutional and Administrative Law · The Implementation and Enforcement of EU Law in Belgium · Judicial Dialogue Between Belgian Courts, Constitutional Courts, and the CJEU · National Constitutional Identity and Its Role in EU Law · Fundamental Rights Protection in Belgian and EU Law · Migration, Asylum and Citizenship in Belgian and EU Law · Tax, Competition, Environmental and Social Law in the Belgian and EU Context · The Competences of the CJEU in Politically Sensitive Areas, Including Defence and CFSP
Why it matters
The interplay between national public law and European Union law is a critical area of study, particularly for member states like BEL. The decisions made at the EU level frequently impact national legal frameworks, necessitating continuous adaptation and interpretation. Understanding these dynamics is essential for maintaining legal coherence and ensuring the effective functioning of both national and supranational governance.
This event offers a timely opportunity to delve into specific areas where these legal systems converge and diverge. Topics such as administrative discretion, as defined in legal scholarship, and the role of administrative tribunals are central to understanding how EU directives are implemented and enforced at the national level. The discussions will likely highlight areas of tension and best practices, contributing to a more nuanced understanding of legal integration.
The insights gained from this conference are not limited to BEL. The challenges and perspectives discussed can offer valuable lessons for other member states as they navigate similar legal complexities. The event's focus on interactions and challenges underscores the ongoing need for legal professionals to stay abreast of developments in both national and EU law to ensure effective legal practice and policy formulation.
How to prepare
To prepare effectively for this event, participants should undertake a thorough review of recent developments in both Belgian public law and European Union law. A particular focus on areas where these two legal systems intersect, such as administrative law, constitutional law, and fundamental rights, would be beneficial. Understanding the historical evolution of this relationship and key judicial precedents from both Belgian courts and the Court of Justice of the European Union will provide a strong foundation for engaging in discussions.
Participants should consider how specific EU regulations or directives have been transposed into Belgian law and the practical implications of these transpositions. Analyzing case studies or recent legal challenges that illustrate the interactions and potential conflicts between the two legal orders would be particularly insightful. This preparation will enable attendees to contribute meaningfully to the discourse and to identify areas for further research or policy development.
Engaging with the concepts of "administrative discretion" and the functioning of "administrative tribunals" within the Belgian legal system, in light of EU legal principles, will be crucial. Participants could also benefit from familiarizing themselves with the Model Diplomat lessons on "dynamic-analysis" and "what-is-stakeholder-mapping" to better understand the various actors and influences at play in legal policy formulation. Preparing specific questions related to the practical implications of EU law on Belgian administrative tribunals would also enhance participation.
Country perspectives
Where the most-relevant 1 countries stand on the core issues in play. Click through for the full country profile.
Topics & background
The background behind each topic and the actors that shape it.
The Influence of EU Law on Belgian Constitutional and Administrative Law
Key players
BelgiumMember State whose constitutional and administrative law is shaped by EU integration
GermanyComparative reference point given the Bundesverfassungsgericht's constitutional-identity case law
FranceCivil-law neighbour influencing Belgian administrative-law doctrine and Conseil d'État practice
NetherlandsBenelux partner with closely aligned monist approach to EU law
LuxembourgHost of the CJEU and Benelux partner shaping shared legal traditions
The Implementation and Enforcement of EU Law in Belgium
Key players
BelgiumMember State responsible for transposing and enforcing EU law across federal entities
LuxembourgSeat of the CJEU which hears infringement actions against Belgium
GermanyFederal Member State offering comparative models for multilevel transposition
FranceKey partner influencing Belgian regulatory choices and EU legislative direction
NetherlandsBenelux partner with parallel implementation practices
Judicial Dialogue Between Belgian Courts, Constitutional Courts, and the CJEU
Key players
BelgiumHome of active referring courts shaping the EU preliminary reference system
LuxembourgSeat of the CJEU, interlocutor in preliminary reference dialogue
GermanySource of influential constitutional-pluralism jurisprudence (Solange, PSPP)
ItalyConstitutional Court whose Taricco saga shaped controlimiti doctrine
FranceConseil d'État and Conseil constitutionnel providing comparative dialogue models
PolandCounter-example illustrating risks of judicial confrontation with the CJEU
National Constitutional Identity and Its Role in EU Law
Key players
BelgiumFederal Member State whose identity claims focus on linguistic and federal structures
GermanyPrincipal architect of constitutional-identity review through the Bundesverfassungsgericht
FranceConseil constitutionnel pioneer of 'inherent constitutional identity' doctrine
PolandTribunal that invoked identity to challenge EU primacy in 2021
HungaryConstitutional Court advancing identity-based resistance to EU norms
ItalySource of the controlimiti doctrine balancing primacy and constitutional core
Fundamental Rights Protection in Belgian and EU Law
Key players
BelgiumMember State integrating constitutional, ECHR, and Charter rights protection
LuxembourgSeat of the CJEU interpreting the Charter of Fundamental Rights
FranceHost of the ECtHR in Strasbourg and key actor in EU rights jurisprudence
GermanyPioneer of fundamental-rights review of EU acts and Charter dialogue
NetherlandsActive participant in Charter-based preliminary references
Migration, Asylum and Citizenship in Belgian and EU Law
Key players
BelgiumMember State implementing the CEAS and host of EU migration institutions
GermanyLargest destination state shaping EU migration policy
GreeceFrontline external-border state central to Dublin and Pact debates
ItalyMediterranean frontline state driving solidarity discussions
FranceMajor destination and policy entrepreneur in the EU Pact negotiations
NetherlandsBenelux partner coordinating border and asylum policy with Belgium
Tax, Competition, Environmental and Social Law in the Belgian and EU Context
Key players
BelgiumMember State implementing EU regulatory regimes across federal entities
IrelandComparator on EU state-aid tax rulings (Apple case)
LuxembourgTax-policy peer and seat of the CJEU on competition appeals
GermanyLeading shaper of EU competition and environmental rules
FranceDriver of EU industrial, environmental, and social-policy agendas
NetherlandsTax-policy peer and partner in EU Green Deal implementation
The Competences of the CJEU in Politically Sensitive Areas, Including Defence and CFSP
Key players
BelgiumHost of NATO and EU institutions, engaged in defence-industrial policy debates
LuxembourgSeat of the CJEU testing the limits of CFSP jurisdiction
FranceLeading advocate of EU strategic autonomy and defence integration
GermanyMajor contributor to EU sanctions and defence policy with constitutional sensitivities
RussiaTarget of EU restrictive measures driving sanctions litigation
UkraineBeneficiary of EU defence and financial assistance shaping new legal instruments
Resources
News, lessons, and country profiles to prep for Belgian Public Law and European Union Law: Interactions, Challenges and Perspectives.
Lessons
Bite-sized lessons to build the basics
Courses
Guided courses that go deeper on the topic
The states in play, with the data that shapes their stance
Related conferences
By committee
- The Influence of EU Law on Belgian Constitutional and Administrative Law
- The Implementation and Enforcement of EU Law in Belgium
- Judicial Dialogue Between Belgian Courts, Constitutional Courts, and the CJEU
- National Constitutional Identity and Its Role in EU Law
- Fundamental Rights Protection in Belgian and EU Law
- Migration, Asylum and Citizenship in Belgian and EU Law
- Tax, Competition, Environmental and Social Law in the Belgian and EU Context
- The Competences of the CJEU in Politically Sensitive Areas, Including Defence and CFSP