Studying History & Current Events
Historiography, primary vs secondary sources, periodization — how historians actually think.
Sources
Primary vs secondary vs tertiary
Primary
Direct evidence from the period — documents, photos, correspondence, diaries, speeches, interviews, artifacts.
Secondary
Historians' interpretations based on primary sources — monographs, journal articles, textbooks.
Tertiary
Syntheses of secondary work — encyclopedias, textbooks, popular surveys.
Every source has a bias
Doesn't mean it's useless — means you account for it. Churchill's memoirs are invaluable for what he thought; they're unreliable for neutral fact.
Key Points
- Author: who, writing when, for whom?
- Purpose: persuade, record, justify, educate?
- Audience: public vs private? Contemporaneous vs posthumous?
- Position: insider vs outsider? Beneficiary vs critic?
Historiography
What is historiography?
Not history itself — the history of how historians have written about a subject. Why does it matter? Because the current consensus reflects years of evolving interpretation, not just 'the facts.'
Major schools
Whig history
Progressive narrative — history as the story of liberty and reform triumphing. Herbert Butterfield critiqued this in 1931 but it persists in popular history.
Annales school
French, 20th century. Longue durée — structures, mentalities, everyday life — over great-men narratives.
Marxist
Class struggle as engine. Hobsbawm, E.P. Thompson, Eric Williams.
Subaltern / postcolonial
Ranajit Guha, Dipesh Chakrabarty. Write history from the perspective of those excluded from elite sources.
Microhistory
Zoom in on a single village, family, or life to reveal larger structures. Ginzburg's 'The Cheese and the Worms.'
Revisionism (the real kind)
Every generation revisits settled questions. Cold War origins, the causes of WWI, the Reconstruction period — all have been substantially rewritten. Revisionism is the healthy norm, not a slur.
Periodization
Traditional periods (Western)
Key Points
- Ancient: ~3000 BCE – 500 CE (fall of western Rome).
- Medieval / Middle Ages: 500 – 1500.
- Early Modern: 1500 – 1800 (contested start and end).
- Modern: 1800 – 1945.
- Contemporary: 1945 – present.
Periodization is interpretation
Dividing time into periods is itself an argument. 'Middle Ages' implies a fall-and-renaissance narrative; 'early modern' implies continuity into the present. Non-Western historiographies (China's dynasties, Islamic caliphates) use entirely different divisions.
Long time vs event time
Braudel's three tiers: event-time (days-years), conjuncture (decades), longue durée (centuries — geography, climate, institutions). Good history moves between them.
Study Workflow
How to research a topic
Key Points
- Start with a good secondary overview — the Very Short Introductions series (OUP) is excellent for orientation.
- Identify the key debates and the main camps.
- Read the 'classic' primary sources referenced in the literature.
- Read a recent journal article to find the current state of the debate.
- Follow references backwards and forwards (citing articles).
Taking notes
Don't just highlight. Write notes in your own words.
Key Points
- Summarize each paragraph in one sentence.
- Write the argument of the whole piece in 2-3 sentences.
- Note the author's school, evidence, and the single weakest point in the argument.
- File notes by theme, not by source — you'll find connections faster when writing.
FAQ
Is Wikipedia a legitimate source?
For orientation, yes. For citation, use Wikipedia to find the real sources in its references. Good Wikipedia articles on contested topics are often better than popular books — but always verify claims via sourced citations.
Can history be objective?
Historians aim for rigor, evidence, and methodological transparency — not neutrality. Every history is written from a standpoint. The test is how well the work uses its sources and engages alternatives.
Continue learning
Explore related MUN guides to deepen your skills.