The Ad Hoc Committee on Cybercrime is the informal name for the UN body formally titled the Ad Hoc Committee to Elaborate a Comprehensive International Convention on Countering the Use of Information and Communications Technologies for Criminal Purposes. It was established by UN General Assembly resolution 74/247 in December 2019, on a proposal led by the Russian Federation and co-sponsored by a group of states including China, Belarus, and several others. The resolution was adopted by a divided vote, with the United States, EU member states, and many Western democracies opposing it on the grounds that it duplicated and risked undermining the existing Council of Europe Budapest Convention on Cybercrime (2001).
The Committee's mandate was to draft a new, universal treaty addressing the criminal misuse of ICTs. It convened multiple negotiating sessions in New York and Vienna between 2022 and 2024, chaired by Ambassador Faouzia Boumaiza Mebarki of Algeria. Sessions were open to member states, with civil society, private sector, academic, and NGO stakeholders admitted as observers.
After several rounds of contested drafting, the Committee concluded its work in August 2024 with a finalized draft convention. Key points of contention throughout negotiations included:
- The scope of criminalized conduct (whether to cover only "cyber-dependent" crimes or also content-related offenses).
- Human rights safeguards, including protections for security researchers, journalists, and whistleblowers.
- Cross-border data access and mutual legal assistance provisions.
- Dual criminality requirements and the breadth of surveillance cooperation.
Civil society groups including Access Now, Human Rights Watch, and the Electronic Frontier Foundation, along with major tech industry associations, repeatedly warned that broad provisions could enable transnational repression. The UN General Assembly adopted the resulting convention in late 2024, opening it for signature, though ratification debates remain ongoing in many capitals. The Committee is significant as the first UN-led criminal law treaty negotiation in roughly two decades.
Example
In August 2024, the Ad Hoc Committee, chaired by Algeria's Faouzia Boumaiza Mebarki, concluded its final session in New York by approving a draft UN cybercrime convention for transmission to the General Assembly.
Frequently asked questions
The Budapest Convention (2001), administered by the Council of Europe, is the existing principal cybercrime treaty with over 60 parties. The UN process was launched partly because some states, notably Russia, viewed Budapest as Western-led and sought a universal framework; critics argued the new treaty risked weaker human rights safeguards.
Keep learning