--- title: "Great Nicobar Fight Turns on the Paper Trail" description: "Jairam Ramesh's push for transparency over the Great Nicobar project turns the fight to its paper trail, raising critical environmental and clearance concerns." url: "https://modeldiplomat.com/story/great-nicobar-fight-turns-on-the-paper-trail" --- # Great Nicobar Fight Turns on the Paper Trail Jairam Ramesh challenges environmental claims of the project. Model DiplomatMay 11, 20263 min readAsia [The Indian ExpressRamesh flags inadequate studies for Great Nicobar Project, demands high-powered panel report be made public | India News - The Indian Express](https://indianexpress.com/article/india/ramesh-flags-inadequate-studies-for-great-nicobar-project-demands-high-powered-panel-report-be-made-public-10683045/)[NewsarenaindiaRamesh calls for rethink on Great Nicobar project, writes to Env Min Yadav](https://newsarenaindia.com/nation/ramesh-urges-rethink-on-nicobar-project-writes-to-env-min-yadav/76847)[Himanshu TiwariJairam Ramesh Questions Environmental Clearance for Great Nicobar Project](https://dailykiran.com/jairam-ramesh-questions-environmental-clearance-for-great-nicobar-project/) ## Great Nicobar Fight Turns on the Paper Trail *Jairam Ramesh is attacking the project’s weakest point: the state’s claim that the environmental record is robust while keeping the HPC review secret.* ## Transparency is now the battleground Rajya Sabha MP Jairam Ramesh has forced the Great Nicobar project back into the spotlight by writing to Environment Minister Bhupender Yadav and demanding that the report of the NGT-mandated High-Powered Committee be made public, while arguing that the environmental studies behind the clearance were far too thin to justify the scale of the project ([The Indian Express](https://indianexpress.com/article/india/ramesh-flags-inadequate-studies-for-great-nicobar-project-demands-high-powered-panel-report-be-made-public-10683045/ "indianexpress.com"); [The Hindu](https://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/energy-and-environment/great-nicobar-project-will-destroy-unique-ecosystem-pause-revisit-venture-ramesh-to-environment-minister/article70961934.ece "thehindu.com")). His core charge is not rhetorical: the final EIA, he says, was built on one winter-season study from December 2020 to February 2021, with biodiversity and turtle surveys lasting only days ([The Indian Express](https://indianexpress.com/article/india/ramesh-flags-inadequate-studies-for-great-nicobar-project-demands-high-powered-panel-report-be-made-public-10683045/ "indianexpress.com"); [The Tribune](https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/india/mockery-of-eia-process-jairam-ramesh-flags-bogus-afforestation-claims-on-great-nicobar-project/ "tribuneindia.com")). That matters because the government has already made the project’s strategic case: it says Great Nicobar is meant to strengthen India’s presence in the Andaman Sea while balancing port-led growth, environmental safeguards, and indigenous protections ([The Hindu](https://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/energy-and-environment/great-nicobar-project-will-destroy-unique-ecosystem-pause-revisit-venture-ramesh-to-environment-minister/article70961934.ece "thehindu.com")). In other words, the Centre is relying on the argument that national interest can coexist with mitigation; Ramesh is trying to show the mitigation record does not meet the legal test. ## The real weakness is procedural The leverage point is the HPC report. The NGT’s February 2026 decision upheld the environmental clearance and said there was “no good ground to interfere,” but that ruling rested on the committee’s conclusions rather than the report being placed fully in the public domain, according to both [The Indian Express](https://indianexpress.com/article/india/ramesh-flags-inadequate-studies-for-great-nicobar-project-demands-high-powered-panel-report-be-made-public-10683045/ "indianexpress.com") and [Frontline](https://frontline.thehindu.com/environment/great-nicobar-project-ngt-clearance-environmental-concerns-india/article70648421.ece "frontline.thehindu.com"). That gives Ramesh an opening: if the report is withheld on “confidentiality” grounds, the government looks like it is asking for deference without disclosure. This is also why the debate has outgrown the usual environment-versus-development frame. [Frontline](https://frontline.thehindu.com/environment/great-nicobar-project-ngt-clearance-environmental-concerns-india/article70648421.ece "frontline.thehindu.com") noted that the project’s strategic logic is tied to India’s proximity to the Malacca Strait and to a larger Indian Ocean posture, which gives the Centre a national-security rationale that courts and tribunals have already been willing to weigh heavily. But that same logic raises the cost of opacity: the more the government says the project is strategic, the more critics will demand proof that environmental law was still followed. ## Who gains, who loses For now, the **Centre holds the operating advantage** because the NGT has already upheld the clearance and the project is framed as a strategic asset ([Frontline](https://frontline.thehindu.com/environment/great-nicobar-project-ngt-clearance-environmental-concerns-india/article70648421.ece "frontline.thehindu.com")). Ramesh and Congress benefit politically if they can turn the HPC secrecy issue into a broader transparency case, especially since the government itself released FAQs claiming the ecological impacts were comprehensively assessed ([The Indian Express](https://indianexpress.com/article/india/ramesh-flags-inadequate-studies-for-great-nicobar-project-demands-high-powered-panel-report-be-made-public-10683045/ "indianexpress.com")). The losers, if the project proceeds unchanged, are the island’s fragile ecosystems and the government’s claim that this is a cleanly managed strategic build-out. ## What to watch next The next decisive move is whether Bhupender Yadav releases the HPC report or doubles down on confidentiality. If he refuses, the fight shifts from environmental merits to disclosure and judicial review — with the Calcutta High Court still a live venue in the wider challenge, according to [The Hindu](https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/congress-says-ngt-clearing-great-nicobar-project-is-deeply-disappointing/article70638963.ece "thehindu.com") and [Frontline](https://frontline.thehindu.com/environment/why-national-green-tribunal-cleared-great-nicobar-island-project-despite-ecological-risks/article70661022.ece "frontline.thehindu.com"). For more on the politics around sensitive infrastructure disputes, see [India](https://modeldiplomat.com/discover/india "modeldiplomat.com") and [Global Politics](https://modeldiplomat.com/discover/general "modeldiplomat.com"). [Great Nicobar](https://modeldiplomat.com/tag/great-nicobar)[Jairam Ramesh](https://modeldiplomat.com/tag/jairam-ramesh)[Environmental Policy](https://modeldiplomat.com/tag/environmental-policy)[Transparency](https://modeldiplomat.com/tag/transparency)[India](https://modeldiplomat.com/tag/india) Discover more [India](https://modeldiplomat.com/story/bjps-delimitation-strategy-women-as-political-shields) #### [BJP's Delimitation Strategy](https://modeldiplomat.com/story/bjps-delimitation-strategy-women-as-political-shields) [Congress leader K.C. Venugopal claims the BJP uses women's reservation to advance delimitation, raising fears over electoral fairness ahead of the 2029 polls.](https://modeldiplomat.com/story/bjps-delimitation-strategy-women-as-political-shields) [India](https://modeldiplomat.com/story/congress-critiques-modi-government-on-womens-reservation-bill) #### [Congress Accuses Modi of Stalling Women's Law](https://modeldiplomat.com/story/congress-critiques-modi-government-on-womens-reservation-bill) [Congress accuses Modi of stalling women's reservation law by linking it to delimitation, revealing a deeper electoral strategy.](https://modeldiplomat.com/story/congress-critiques-modi-government-on-womens-reservation-bill) [India](https://modeldiplomat.com/story/cpim-pushes-to-decouple-quota-policy-from-delimitation-in-india) #### [CPI(M) Calls to Decouple Quota from Delimita](https://modeldiplomat.com/story/cpim-pushes-to-decouple-quota-policy-from-delimitation-in-india) [CPI(M) advocates for a 33% women's quota in Lok Sabha by 2029, removing the need for delimitation and census linkage.](https://modeldiplomat.com/story/cpim-pushes-to-decouple-quota-policy-from-delimitation-in-india) [Economics](https://modeldiplomat.com/story/feds-amex-aml-order-puts-correspondent-banking-on-notice) #### [Fed's Amex AML order puts correspondent banking on notice](https://modeldiplomat.com/story/feds-amex-aml-order-puts-correspondent-banking-on-notice) [Federal Reserve's Amex AML order requires board-level controls and a 90-day plan; OCC fined the bank $350 million over enterprise-wide deficiencies.](https://modeldiplomat.com/story/feds-amex-aml-order-puts-correspondent-banking-on-notice)