A resolved statement (often just called "the resolution" or "the motion") is the single declarative sentence that defines what a deliberative body is being asked to decide. In parliamentary and academic debate it conventionally opens with "Resolved: that..." followed by an action, judgment, or policy claim. The wording fixes the scope of debate: speakers must address the proposition as written, and the chair rules out arguments deemed outside its terms.
In Model UN, the resolved clauses (sometimes called "operative clauses") of a draft resolution function as the binding text the committee votes on, while preambular clauses provide context. Each operative clause typically begins with an action verb — Calls upon, Requests, Decides, Condemns — and is numbered. Only operative language has effect if adopted.
In competitive debate formats such as Lincoln-Douglas, Policy (CX), and Public Forum, the resolved statement is the season's or round's topic. The National Speech & Debate Association in the United States, for example, releases a new Policy topic each August and rotating LD and PF topics throughout the year. The affirmative side must defend the resolution; the negative challenges it.
Resolved statements fall into recognized categories:
- Resolutions of fact — assert that something is or is not true.
- Resolutions of value — claim something is good, just, or preferable.
- Resolutions of policy — call for a specific action, usually identified by the word should.
Drafting matters: ambiguous wording invites definitional disputes ("topicality" arguments in Policy debate), while overly narrow wording can predetermine the outcome. In legislative bodies, parliamentary procedure (e.g., Robert's Rules of Order) treats the motion as the property of the assembly once seconded, meaning it can only be altered through formal amendment. The resolved statement therefore serves as both the anchor of debate and the precise text of any decision ultimately taken.
Example
At the 2023 National Speech & Debate Tournament, Policy debaters argued the resolved statement that the United States federal government should substantially increase fiscal redistribution in the United States by adopting a federal jobs guarantee, expanding Social Security, and/or providing a basic income.
Frequently asked questions
They overlap. A motion is any formal proposal put to a body; a resolved statement is a motion phrased as a declarative resolution, typically beginning with 'Resolved' and intended for a recorded vote rather than a procedural decision.
Keep learning